blupf90으로 single trait random regression model의 육종가 구하기

 

R. A. Mrode, Linear Models for the prediction of Animal Breeding Values, 2nd Edition. p144 Example 7.2

 

data

 

4 1 4 17.0

4 2 38 18.6

4 3 72 24.0

4 4 106 20.0

4 5 140 20.0

4 6 174 15.6

4 7 208 16.0

4 8 242 13.0

4 9 276 8.2

4 10 310 8.0

5 1 4 23.0

5 2 38 21.0

5 3 72 18.0

5 4 106 17.0

5 5 140 16.2

5 6 174 14.0

5 7 208 14.2

5 8 242 13.4

5 9 276 11.8

5 10 310 11.4

6 6 4 10.4

6 7 38 12.3

6 8 72 13.2

6 9 106 11.6

6 10 140 8.4

7 4 4 22.8

7 5 38 22.4

7 6 72 21.4

7 7 106 18.8

7 8 140 18.3

7 9 174 16.2

7 10 208 15.0

8 1 4 22.2

8 2 38 20.0

8 3 72 21.0

8 4 106 23.0

8 5 140 16.8

8 6 174 11.0

8 7 208 13.0

8 8 242 17.0

8 9 276 13.0

8 10 310 12.6

 

animal, htd(herd-test-day), dim(days-in-milk), test day fat yield

 

data.txt로 저장

 

renumf90(blupf90)random regression model을 위한 다항식(polynomial)을 자동으로 만들어 주지 않는다. 그래서 미리 dim에 대한 다항식을 만들어 주어야 한다. dim에 대한 다항식 만드는 방법에 대해서는 fixed regress model을 참고.

 

다음은 다항식을 data.txt의 왼쪽에 붙여 만든 data_2.txt의 내용이다.

 

0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 4 1 4 17.0

0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 4 2 38 18.6

0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 4 3 72 24.0

0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 4 4 106 20.0

0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 4 5 140 20.0

0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 -0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 4 6 174 15.6

0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 -0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439465 4 7 208 16.0

0.707106781186548 0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 -0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 4 8 242 13.0

0.707106781186548 0.95257934441568 0.64416767151578 0.0179640615277207 -0.620456293139912 4 9 276 8.2

0.707106781186548 1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 4 10 310 8.0

0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 5 1 4 23.0

0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 5 2 38 21.0

0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 5 3 72 18.0

0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 5 4 106 17.0

0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 5 5 140 16.2

0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 -0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 5 6 174 14.0

0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 -0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439465 5 7 208 14.2

0.707106781186548 0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 -0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 5 8 242 13.4

0.707106781186548 0.95257934441568 0.64416767151578 0.0179640615277207 -0.620456293139912 5 9 276 11.8

0.707106781186548 1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 5 10 310 11.4

0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 6 6 4 10.4

0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 6 7 38 12.3

0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 6 8 72 13.2

0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 6 9 106 11.6

0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 6 10 140 8.4

0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 7 4 4 22.8

0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 7 5 38 22.4

0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 7 6 72 21.4

0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 7 7 106 18.8

0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 7 8 140 18.3

0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 -0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 7 9 174 16.2

0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 -0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439465 7 10 208 15.0

0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 8 1 4 22.2

0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 8 2 38 20.0

0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 8 3 72 21.0

0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 8 4 106 23.0

0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 8 5 140 16.8

0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 -0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 8 6 174 11.0

0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 -0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439465 8 7 208 13.0

0.707106781186548 0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 -0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 8 8 242 17.0

0.707106781186548 0.95257934441568 0.64416767151578 0.0179640615277207 -0.620456293139912 8 9 276 13.0

0.707106781186548 1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 8 10 310 12.6

 

 

pedigree

 

1 0 0

2 0 0

3 0 0

4 1 2

5 3 2

6 1 5

7 3 4

8 1 7

 

pedi.txt로 저장

 

renumf90을 위한 parameter 파일 작성

 

# Parameter file for program renf90; it is translated to parameter

# file for BLUPF90 family programs.

DATAFILE

data_2.txt

TRAITS

9

FIELDS_PASSED TO OUTPUT

 

WEIGHT(S)

 

RESIDUAL_VARIANCE

3.71

EFFECT

7 cross numer

EFFECT

1 cov

EFFECT

2 cov

EFFECT

3 cov

EFFECT

4 cov

EFFECT

5 cov

EFFECT

6 cross alpha

RANDOM

animal

OPTIONAL

pe

FILE

pedi.txt

FILE_POS

1 2 3

PED_DEPTH

0

RANDOM_REGRESSION

data

RR_POSITION

1 2 3

(CO)VARIANCES

3.297 0.594 -1.381

0.594 0.921 -0.289

-1.381 -0.289 1.005

(CO)VARIANCES_PE

6.872 -0.254 -1.101

-0.254 3.171 0.167

-1.101 0.167 2.457

 

설명

 

DATAFILE

data_2.txt

 

자료 파일 이름

 

TRAITS

9

 

자료 파일에서 관측치의 위치(컬럼)

 

FIELDS_PASSED TO OUTPUT

 

WEIGHT(S)

 

RESIDUAL_VARIANCE

3.71

 

잔차 분산

 

EFFECT

7 cross numer

 

7 컬럼(HTD:herd-test-day)이 고정효과로 쓰임

 

셋째 컬럼이 고정효과로 쓰임

 

EFFECT

1 cov

EFFECT

2 cov

EFFECT

3 cov

EFFECT

4 cov

EFFECT

5 cov

 

첫째 컬럼에서 다섯째 컬럼이 회귀 변수

 

EFFECT

6 cross alpha

 

6째 컬럼이 분류 효과(숫자로 되어 있어도 alpha로 하기 바란다. numer로 하면 제대로 처리가 되지 않는다.)

 

RANDOM

animal

 

임의 개체 효과

 

OPTIONAL

pe

 

개체의 자료가 중복됨에 따라 영구 환경 효과 추가

 

FILE

pedi.txt

 

혈통 파일 이름

 

FILE_POS

1 2 3

 

혈통 파일은 animal, sire, dam

 

PED_DEPTH

0

 

끝까지 혈통 추적

 

RANDOM_REGRESSION

data

 

임의 회귀 변수임을 선언(회귀 변수가 이 효과에 nested 된다는 의미)

 

RR_POSITION

1 2 3

 

개체 효과에 nested 되는 회귀 변수 지정(order = 3)

 

(CO)VARIANCES

3.297 0.594 -1.381

0.594 0.921 -0.289

-1.381 -0.289 1.005

 

개체 효과 분산-공분산 행렬

 

(CO)VARIANCES_PE

6.872 -0.254 -1.101

-0.254 3.171 0.167

-1.101 0.167 2.457

 

영구 환경 효과의 분산

 

실행 화면

 





생성된 파일

 

renf90.tables

 

Effect group 1 of column 1 with 10 levels, effect # 1

Value # consecutive number

1 3 1

2 3 2

3 3 3

4 4 4

5 4 5

6 5 6

7 5 7

8 5 8

9 5 9

10 5 10

 

고정효과 : 원래 번호, 개수, 새로운 번호

 

renf90.dat

 

17.0 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 1 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 4

18.6 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 2 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 4

24.0 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 3 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 4

20.0 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 4 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 4

20.0 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 5 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 4

15.6 0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 6 0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 -0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 4

16.0 0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 7 0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 -0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439465 4

13.0 0.707106781186548 0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 8 0.707106781186548 0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 -0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 4

8.2 0.707106781186548 0.95257934441568 0.64416767151578 9 0.707106781186548 0.95257934441568 0.64416767151578 0.0179640615277207 -0.620456293139912 4

8.0 0.707106781186548 1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 10 0.707106781186548 1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 4

23.0 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 1 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 1

21.0 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 2 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 1

18.0 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 3 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 1

17.0 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 4 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 1

16.2 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 5 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 1

14.0 0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 6 0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 -0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 1

14.2 0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 7 0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 -0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439465 1

13.4 0.707106781186548 0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 8 0.707106781186548 0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 -0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 1

11.8 0.707106781186548 0.95257934441568 0.64416767151578 9 0.707106781186548 0.95257934441568 0.64416767151578 0.0179640615277207 -0.620456293139912 1

11.4 0.707106781186548 1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 10 0.707106781186548 1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 1

10.4 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 6 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 3

12.3 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 7 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 3

13.2 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 8 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 3

11.6 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 9 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 3

8.4 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 10 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 3

22.8 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 4 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 5

22.4 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 5 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 5

21.4 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 6 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 5

18.8 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 7 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 5

18.3 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 8 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 5

16.2 0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 9 0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 -0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 5

15.0 0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 10 0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 -0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439465 5

22.2 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 1 0.707106781186548 -1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 -1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 2

20.0 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 2 0.707106781186548 -0.95257934441568 0.644167671515781 -0.0179640615277216 -0.620456293139911 2

21.0 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 3 0.707106781186548 -0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 2

23.0 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 4 0.707106781186548 -0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439461 2

16.8 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 5 0.707106781186548 -0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 2

11.0 0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 6 0.707106781186548 0.136082763487954 -0.761289066336832 -0.305389045971261 0.698700390555157 2

13.0 0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 7 0.707106781186548 0.408248290463863 -0.52704627669473 -0.762189467676173 0.0261891400439465 2

17.0 0.707106781186548 0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 8 0.707106781186548 0.680413817439772 -0.0585606974105255 -0.757056878668253 -0.775651197104036 2

13.0 0.707106781186548 0.95257934441568 0.64416767151578 9 0.707106781186548 0.95257934441568 0.64416767151578 0.0179640615277207 -0.620456293139912 2

12.6 0.707106781186548 1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 10 0.707106781186548 1.22474487139159 1.58113883008419 1.87082869338697 2.12132034355964 2

  

trait1, 임의회귀 개체효과1 - 임의회귀 개체효과3, HTD, 고정회귀변수1 고정회귀변수3, 개체효과

 

renadd03.ped

 

1 8 7 1 0 2 10 0 1 5

8 0 0 3 0 0 0 2 0 3

2 6 5 1 0 2 10 0 0 8

6 0 0 3 0 0 0 3 0 1

3 6 1 1 0 2 5 0 0 6

4 6 7 1 0 2 10 0 1 4

7 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 2 2

5 8 4 1 0 2 7 0 1 7

 

renumbered 된 혈통. 자세한 설명은 single trait animal model 참조

 

renf90.par

 

# BLUPF90 parameter file created by RENF90

DATAFILE

renf90.dat

NUMBER_OF_TRAITS

1

NUMBER_OF_EFFECTS

12

OBSERVATION(S)

1

WEIGHT(S)

EFFECTS: POSITIONS_IN_DATAFILE NUMBER_OF_LEVELS TYPE_OF_EFFECT[EFFECT NESTED]

5 10 cross

6 1 cov

7 1 cov

8 1 cov

9 1 cov

10 1 cov

2 8 cov 11

3 8 cov 11

4 8 cov 11

2 8 cov 11

3 8 cov 11

4 8 cov 11

RANDOM_RESIDUAL VALUES

3.710000

RANDOM_GROUP

7 8 9

RANDOM_TYPE

add_animal

FILE

renadd07.ped

(CO)VARIANCES

3.297000 0.5940000 -1.381000

0.5940000 0.9210000 -0.2890000

-1.381000 -0.2890000 1.005000

RANDOM_GROUP

10 11 12

RANDOM_TYPE

diagonal

FILE

(CO)VARIANCES

6.872000 -0.2540000 -1.101000

-0.2540000 3.171000 0.1670000

-1.101000 0.1670000 2.457000

 

설명

 

DATAFILE

renf90.dat

 

자료 파일의 이름

 

NUMBER_OF_TRAITS

1

 

형질의 수

 

NUMBER_OF_EFFECTS

12

 

효과의 수(htd, dim1 ~ dim5, 개체효과1 ~ 개체효과3, 영구환경효과1 ~ 영구환경효과3)

 

OBSERVATION(S)

1

 

관측치의 위치

 

WEIGHT(S)

EFFECTS: POSITIONS_IN_DATAFILE NUMBER_OF_LEVELS TYPE_OF_EFFECT[EFFECT NESTED]

5 10 cross

6 1 cov

7 1 cov

8 1 cov

9 1 cov

10 1 cov

2 8 cov 11

3 8 cov 11

4 8 cov 11

2 8 cov 11

3 8 cov 11

4 8 cov 11

 

다섯째 컬럼이 효과. 레벨 개수는 10, 분류 효과

여섯째 컬럼에서 열째 컬럼이 연속 변수 효과.

둘째 컬럼에서 넷째 컬럼이 연속 변수 효과. 개체 효과와 영구 환경 효과로 쓰일 것이므로 두 번 쓰임

 

 

RANDOM_RESIDUAL VALUES

3.710000

 

잔차 효과의 분산

 

RANDOM_GROUP

7 8 9

 

효과 중 일곱째에서 아홉째 효과가 임의 효과 그룹

 

RANDOM_TYPE

add_animal

 

additive genetic animal effect

 

FILE

renadd07.ped

 

혈통 파일의 이름

 

(CO)VARIANCES

3.297000 0.5940000 -1.381000

0.5940000 0.9210000 -0.2890000

-1.381000 -0.2890000 1.005000

 

개체 효과의 분산-공분산 행렬

 

RANDOM_GROUP

10 11 12

 

효과 중 열째 효과에서 열두째가 임의 효과

 

RANDOM_TYPE

diagonal

 

영구 환경 효과이므로 diagonal

 

FILE

 

 

파일 지정하지 않음


(CO)VARIANCES

6.872000 -0.2540000 -1.101000

-0.2540000 3.171000 0.1670000

-1.101000 0.1670000 2.457000

 

영구 환경 효과의 분산-공분산 행렬

 

blupf90 실행 화면

 





solutions 결과 파일

 

trait/effect level solution

1 1 1 13.75528202

1 1 2 11.25996236

1 1 3 12.22924685

1 1 4 11.91212085

1 1 5 9.98521457

1 1 6 6.67922242

1 1 7 6.77765335

1 1 8 6.84095218

1 1 9 4.17359916

1 1 10 3.66918671

1 2 1 11.44926728

1 3 1 -0.62539157

1 4 1 -0.13457792

1 5 1 0.34791064

1 6 1 -0.42175200

1 7 1 -0.45375131

1 7 2 0.22083236

1 7 3 -0.54855595

1 7 4 0.34454297

1 7 5 0.85183658

1 7 6 -0.05832534

1 7 7 -0.07283681

1 7 8 0.13115737

1 8 1 -0.05201238

1 8 2 0.01271886

1 8 3 0.07301430

1 8 4 0.00627371

1 8 5 -0.00947069

1 8 6 0.05520153

1 8 7 -0.03051505

1 8 8 -0.02466526

1 9 1 0.27980869

1 9 2 -0.01743426

1 9 3 0.19456422

1 9 4 -0.31640867

1 9 5 -0.31309002

1 9 6 -0.04417675

1 9 7 -0.02437567

1 9 8 0.06853337

1 10 1 -0.77612671

1 10 2 -0.10131195

1 10 3 -1.99267893

1 10 4 -0.64859053

1 10 5 3.51874830

1 10 6 0.00000000

1 10 7 0.00000000

1 10 8 0.00000000

1 11 1 0.13701010

1 11 2 0.28888733

1 11 3 0.98510143

1 11 4 -0.36003168

1 11 5 -1.05097953

1 11 6 0.00000000

1 11 7 0.00000000

1 11 8 0.00000000

1 12 1 0.96883255

1 12 2 0.97706292

1 12 3 -0.06930251

1 12 4 -1.47182321

1 12 5 -0.40471878

1 12 6 0.00000000

1 12 7 0.00000000

1 12 8 0.00000000

 

결과 정리

 

HTD

level

solution

1

13.7553

2

11.2600

3

12.2292

4

11.9121

5

9.9852

6

6.6792

7

6.7777

8

6.8410

9

4.1736

10

3.6692

 

fixed regression

level

solution

1

11.4493

1

-0.6254

1

-0.1346

1

0.3479

1

-0.4218

 

animal - regression coefficient

level

solution1

solution2

solution3

original ID

1

-0.4538

-0.0520

0.2798

5

2

0.2208

0.0127

-0.0174

8

3

-0.5486

0.0730

0.1946

6

4

0.3445

0.0063

-0.3164

4

5

0.8518

-0.0095

-0.3131

7

6

-0.0583

0.0552

-0.0442

1

7

-0.0728

-0.0305

-0.0244

2

8

0.1312

-0.0247

0.0685

3

 

permanent environment effects - regression coefficient

level

solution1

solution2

solution3

original ID

1

-0.7761

0.1370

0.9688

5

2

-0.1013

0.2889

0.9771

8

3

-1.9927

0.9851

-0.0693

6

4

-0.6486

-0.3600

-1.4718

4

5

3.5187

-1.0510

-0.4047

7

6

 

 

 

1

7

 

 

 

2

8

 

 

 

3

 

관련 파일


+ Recent posts